We Missed a Spot: What a Roof Flashing Fix Taught Us (and Can Teach You)

We'll say it first: we got this one wrong

We recently finished a beautiful roof on a large home, about 60 squares, which is bigger than most of the roofs we do. The shingle work was excellent. Our roofer did a tremendous job.
But while he was up there, he noticed something off about the counter flashing, the metal that covers the joint where the roof meets the brick. Whoever installed it originally ran it about 12 inches up the brick, when around 4 inches would have done the job.
He wanted to make it look better, so he bent new metal around it and spray-painted the old, weathered flashing. That's a pretty common approach, and his heart was absolutely in the right place. The problem? Our roofer is a great roofer, not a metal trim specialist. The result didn't look any better than before. And the glossy paint he used made every imperfection shine, literally. (Lesson learned: matte paint hides things. Gloss puts them in a spotlight.)
We caught it before anyone had to tell us
Every Kenco roof gets a follow-up inspection, and that's where we spotted it. Before the homeowner raised a single concern, we told him plainly: this isn't up to our standards.
Then we went back to the office and talked it through as a team. The answer was right under our noses. We have craftsmen on our team who are master aluminum trim workers. All our roofer needed to do was ask for an assist.
So we sent a separate trim crew back out to redo the counter flashing. It looks dramatically better now, and honestly, it's some of the cleanest trim work on the street.
What every homeowner should know about roof flashing
The homeowner also asked a fair question: "Why didn't you replace all of the flashing?"
Here's the answer, and it's something every homeowner with a brick home should know.
Step flashing is the series of small metal pieces woven in with the shingles where the roof meets a wall. We almost always replace it during a new roof.
Counter flashing is the metal that covers the top of the step flashing and attaches to the wall itself. On a brick home, it's usually nailed or screwed into the brick and glued down. Rip it off, and you're left with damaged, discolored brick that looks a lot worse than the flashing ever did.
So on brick homes, we almost never remove counter flashing. If it needs attention, the better move is to seal it where needed or install new counter flashing over the top of it. Your roof stays protected, and your brick keeps its good looks.
We should have walked the homeowner through that before the job started. Now we do.
What we're doing differently
Calling in the specialists. Our roofers are experts at roofing. Our trim crew are experts at trim. From now on, when a roof job involves serious metal trim work, we tap in the trim crew for an assist.
Explaining flashing before we start. Every brick-home roofing customer will hear the step flashing versus counter flashing talk up front, so there are no surprises.
Why we're telling you this
Every contractor makes mistakes. What matters is what happens next: who catches it, who owns it, and who makes it right. We'd rather show you how we handle a miss than pretend we never have one.
Our homeowner ended up with a great roof, better-looking flashing, and a crash course in brick-home roofing. We ended up with a better process. That's a win-win, even if it took a little humble pie to get there.
Have questions about the flashing on your home? Ask us. We're happy to explain what you've got and what makes sense for it.




Comments